Transcript of the show 583
Welcome to Wood Talk. Now here are three guys who like to take big pieces of wood and make them smaller. Marc, Shannon and Matt.
Alright, welcome to show number 5 83. This is kind of a, a bit of a, a different one. Weāre gonna do a little q and a little q and a for you guys. Sure. Of yourself.
You ever sounded.
Thank you. Thanks very much. Welcome. I had nothing to read, so just making it up. Uh, but this is gonna be show 5 83 and oops, all questions kind of episode. So, uh, we did ask for questions on Patreon. We can only really answer a few of those on the show. And you guys left us like 16 questions there, so we wanna do our best to answer them as, as good as we can.
The reality is we may not have great answers. Because this is not preselected. Weāre just reading them and making sure you guys get your, uh, your voices heard, and then maybe who knows, someone listening might have an answer for you that can, uh, you know, put you in the right direction. So weāre just gonna get through these and, uh, have some fun.
Rich Harwood is the first one I have here. He says, Iāve been woodworking as a hobbyist for about two and a half years now. It seems like the more I learn, the more I understand just how much I donāt know. Iām pretty much obsessed at this point. Tools, styles, techniques, tools. Again, itās like drinking from a fire hose, but Iām still thirsty.
Somehow I still get a reMarcably deep sense of satisfaction touching a freshly hand, plain surface, or getting that perfect friction fit a thousandth of an inch at a time. I dutifully ignore my wife and children to get all the way through the grits. Attaboy, there you go. No skipping grits. I thought after, I thought after this long, some wait.
I thought after this long, some stuff would start. Thatās a weird sentence. Some stuff, uh, would start to be a little bit more mundane, but for the vast majority it hasnāt. I assume, uh, you each had a woodworking is life period. How long did yours last? If it ever ended? Uh, when did other hobbies start working their way back into your life?
Love the show. My wife and young children eagerly await your response. The poor family. So this is actually kind of funny. As we were doing the recording for the last show, I got a couple of texts from my buddy Jason. He is someone who I know through woodworking. We met here at the shop during one of our open houses, but then we kind of became friends over nerd stuff and fitness, and he was a runner, but we started cycling together.
So now he is. Like way down the cycling path. And Shannon, heās, heās like you, heās annoying. Um, he wants to go, he wants to go real fast, right? And heās getting competitive and heās like just trying to be the best cyclist he can. But this hobby now owns him. And I just got a text from him talking about how he is thinking about possibly selling a couple of tools or doing something to move things around in the shop to make room for his bike repair stuff.
Nice. And I think this is just kind of a natural course of things that can happen when you are kind of the serial hobbyist where youāre moving from one thing to another making room. Physically. I just sold
a Veritas plane on eBay, uh, yesterday, in fact. Yeah. Not to, not to buy a bike. I just, you know, like I said several episodes ago, Iām kind of downsizing, but Yeah.
Yeah, itās,
it hits home. Itās, itās common. I mean, the thing is for me, um. I definitely left that phase of it, I guess you would call it like a hobby infatuation, um, quite a while ago, I think. But, but I knew that my connection to woodworking, my love for woodworking was definitely intense enough to make a career change.
Like I want to do this all the time. And even in spite of the things that annoy me about the job part of doing woodworking, I still would rather come into the shop. And make some saw dust and do anything else. Itās still a favorite of mine, but I am definitely not in that like, ah, like we talked about it with, with the Woodcraft stories about the mm-hmm.
The early phases where you would just walk around the store and just daydream about all the cool things you could make. And, uh, these days you probably, rich probably has a couple of YouTube channels that he really likes to watch and he just, you know, maybe. A weirdo like me falls asleep watching some of those things that youāre really interested in.
Right. This is sort of a honeymoon phase. So I, I, I donāt know. As a hobby though, I imagine a lot of people get to the end of that and then maybe theyāre done. They might move on to something else they might do, like Jason and think about selling off all their stuff because they bought some really expensive bikes.
You know, like, and I think thatās okay. But Iām curious, like for you guys weāre all kind of. Like we fell in love with woodworking and then we never let it go uhhuh. We just, we made some changes to make sure that we can continue to do it in an ongoing way, but itās definitely still not the honeymoon phase.
I mean, C are any of us still in the honeymoon phase? No, I donāt think so. Right. No, no. Thereās a practicality to it. Thereās still a love for it, but itās gone to a much more practical place.
Yeah.
I was trying to think about like, when did I lose my honeymoon phase? I mean, it was probably, it had to have been.
More than seven, eight years down the line. Like
when you joined Wood Talk, we all came crashing down. Itās
been a long time on this show too. But yeah, I mean, we kind of talked about it in our burn ride episode. Like each of us has a different perspective than the fact that woodworking became the job. Um, in, in one way, shape, or form.
But youāre right, like itās the passion. Is there enough to be able to make it your job? Um, Iāve found that my love of woodworking is morphed in a number of ways simply because I moved into this kind of commercial industrial side of life. Um, and I still get really excited. Um. Talking to people, building really cool stuff.
Um, and I fortunate to get really exposed to some of the finest home builders in the country and get to help advise them on wood movement stuff and everything. What that sometimes translates to is by the time I get home to my own wood shop, Iām kind of like, ah. And I just go ride my bike. Yeah. Um, so I think some of that happened, but thereās still no question.
I will see a project now and Iāll be like, I just have to build that and I will obsess over it. And I go back to that kind of honeymoon phase where like thatās all youāre thinking about and you canāt wait to go back and start working on that project. I think itās just become, Iāve been able to compartmentalize a little bit, which yeah.
I like to think of as being a little healthy because. You know, like, like you said, you know, neglecting everything else, including my own health, letās be perfectly honest. Uh, really honeymoon phase. Shannon was Fat Shannon, so letās just put it that way. There was, there was, what was it? Somebody commented on our last show thatās like, oh, we all liked Fat Shannon better.
Anyway, so yeah, Iām, Iām claiming that title, but I mean, oh boy, heās older. Discovered I needed to get back in shape and I forgot I remembered how much one of my previous passion cycling was, you know? Mm-hmm. And I, I got back to that. So itās a nice balance and I, I like the fact that I can put together a project, put it in clamps, and go for a bike ride while the glue dries, you know?
Yeah. Itās kind of nice.
I, I mean, for Rich, I would say itās, itās gonna go one of two ways. Like youāre either gonna settle in and itās gonna happen eventually, but who cares if youāre still obsessed with it, run with it. You know, thatās the fun part. Youāre gonna settle in and it sounds like if youāre going this far into it and itās lasting this long, this sounds like it may be a lifetime hobby.
And thatās okay. Like, thatās, thatās the great part about woodworking, is you could do it for a very long time, as long as youāre physically able. Um, and thatāll settle in. The bad news is. For his family. There will likely be something else after this that wonāt be woodworking. Like once it does settle down, rich sounds like the kind of guy whoās probably gonna do like I do and obsess about the next thing, whatever that may be.
He could be like me and not have that happen ever again. Thatās true. No other
obsessions.
I donāt, I donāt have any, Iāve never had that obsessive phase of anything Iāve done since wood. Really? Yeah, because thatās why youāre so
boring, Matt.
Iām sorry, Marc, that I donāt fit your mold of the perfect woodworking experience.
Thatās, well, thatās all the other experiences. Thatās the problem.
Yeah, I was gonna say, it sounds like it is the perfect woodworking experience. This is why
he rides his mother-in-lawās bike. I know. Well,
Shannon, you gotta help prove. Not like, usually doesnāt gonna prove, ah, youāve got nothing but a list of things to prove.
We gotta find you something you can obsess over.
Yeah, but real, like literally Iāve got a fly rod
you can borrow.
I remember. I remember being in this phase. Yeah, it was, um. I started woodworking in 2008. All your
dates were at Woodcraft. We remember. Thatās what Iām talking about. This is brutal. All about it.
That was part of the whole thing. Yeah. I started woodworking in 2008 and I probably ended this phase, like 2012 or something like that, but it was like any magazine, any book, any YouTube, video, anything. Iām, Iām there. Iām watching it. Iām learning. Iām doing, Iām in the shop, Iām building things. Iām practicing.
Iām obsessing over the next project that I wanna make. Literally going through all the steps in my head before I even go out there to do anything with it. And it be, it was like a whole life consuming thing. Whatās hilarious about this, uh, thing from Rich is like the, the woodworking is life, period. Like woodworking literally became my life.
It became life. Yeah. There is no other thing for me. Like you guys have your actual hobbies. I, I donāt have any hobbies that I actually obsess about. Like we talked about, like, I like snowmobiling, but I donāt obsess about it. I donāt care about like the, the stats on the snowmobiles, what the manufacturers are doing, what these different skis can do for you, your perfect shock settings.
Mm-hmm. I do not care. I just go on, go ride. I, I, I donāt care.
Yeah. I. It. It sounds like youāre a healthier person for it. Yeah, probably. Look at me. Iām
so healthy.
I think the people who do what, like I do where youāre jumping and the thing is, I donāt necessarily drop my hobbies. I add things and then I, I was gonna say, and they tone down.
Barbecue
plants spiking. Itās all still there. Yeah. They never
completely go away. I just keep adding more. Itās reflected in his
t-shirts.
Yes. Every time. Yes. Yeah. But itās, I, I honestly think thatās a sign of a unhealthy mental state. I donāt think thatās a great place to be, like being content with the thing youāre into and continuing to do it on a day-to-day basis.
You sound more content than I am. I, I guess, I guess Iāve gone wide with
everything in like the woodworking realm. Like Iāve True, yeah, true woodworking, like furniture making. Then I did like lumber stuff. Iām like, okay, now I can do. Sawing and drying. That makes sense. And now my, now I got machinery I gotta be able to fix.
So like, it, itās, itās widened out. Mm-hmm. I think that has done a lot of
that. Youāre younger than us. Maybe you just havenāt hit that. Like, I think thatās a natural progression. I mean, at this
point though, like, Iām the age that you guys were when I joined the show almost. Yeah. Yeah. Or Marc was at least, uh, Shannon was a little bit older, but Iām the age that Marc was when I started the show with you guys 10 years ago.
Iām just thinking about that normal progression. You know, like, you, you, uh. You, you, you get the bike, you obsess it at it, you get really fit. You focus on your power numbers, and then you kind of donāt care because you canāt hold those power numbers anymore and you stop paying attention or, and now you just like youāre fishing with a fly rod and then you started tying flies.
Then you took an etymology or entomology class to understand how the bugs do it, and now you just wanna go fishing. Yeah. So I hear like
that obsession can ruin things for you too. Like that is definitely something like you do, Shannon. Yeah, right. Of course.
I do think so. You just havenāt, you havenāt gotten far enough, like you have chair kits, but have you really dove down the chair making thing like.
Could you, could you, could you go further and maybe you just get to that point where youāve hit saturation and
Yes. And on that, on that, now youāve finally get a decent bite. Iāve gone down the, the rabbit hole of like manufacturing those things. Mm-hmm. Thatās true on different scale than like the, like the true chair makers are.
But yeah, thatās like, again, thatās just like, just widening the whole thing. Iām not adding the variety things. Yeah. Thereās some variety. So maybe that just keeps me content. ācause Iām always learning and having to do something different. Like I just did the, all the things on Skite. Iāve never done any of that stuff before.
Yeah, but I figured it out
and I did it. You do a lot of metal working. Iām gonna say thatās a separate hobby. Just, just so you can be normal. Oh, thank you. Those
something else. Metal working. Er, just make it, whatever. Just
make it happen. Alright, so thatās 17 minutes for one question. Uh, weāre gonna be here a while, guys.
Yeah. Who wants to hit, hit the next one? That was like a dining room episode topic, I think almost, right? That
could have been a whole show. Uh, Iāll, Iāll take it. Weāre under what, bill? Man? Yeah. Bill. Yeah. Uh, I know you guys are busy. So I appreciate when you produce a show. Hey, hey, hereās another one. I was gifting an eight foot slab of Live Edge cedar slash juniper, about 10 inches thick.
Damn. Um, carpenter, thatās, thatās a canāt, thatās not a slab. Um, a carpenter gave it to me for helping him go, uh, helping him with his. With his go it on. Oh, go it on his own efforts. Um, okay. He donated some tools and Got it. So assuming I can hook up a guy who owns a sawmill other than cheesy flea Marcet childrenās furniture, do you see any good uses for it?
Um, itās too big for our fireplace and not the vibe for our country cottage. So this is one of those, I have a board, what should I build with it? Questions. Those are the best. I never, I never get those questions. Um, man, I donāt know. He, he have any board though. He, like, he
could re
solid to anything. Itās even more abstract.
Thatās what I was thinking, like, you know, you could make, you could make 10 boards. Yeah. Maybe start there if itās 10 inches thick, start by making 10 boards and then go from there. You know, with, with a slab, uh, I think Matt actually did a class about this. You know, you could build whole pieces of furniture from the same slab, um, or you could build 10 pieces of furniture from it.
I, if what youāre asking is, can I do something with cedar slash juniper? Heck yeah. Yes. Itās soft. The, the Juniper variety variant is certainly gonna be. Harder, a little bit more interlocked than like your Western Red Cedar or your Atlantic white. Uh, it was probably a lot knottier. Yeah, it is.
Doesnāt have like a lot more color to it.
I donāt,
yeah, I think so. I think so. Like purples, I think. Um, is that right? So yeah. Iām trying think of something else. Well, you may be thinking aromatic. I donāt dunno what Iām thinking about. Well, I mean all of this it, I donāt even know exactly what heās talking about. There is a line between cedar and juniper, but it could be any number of species.
But in general, youāre the wood guy. Well, but you gotta be more specific than cedar slash juniper. Um. But yeah, I mean, I, Iām, Iām of the mindset that any species can be used for just about anything. Like most of the technical properties of wood is way stronger than anything weāre ever gonna need it for.
So youāre fine. You know, donāt use an exterior wood or an interior wood for exterior. Thatās the one thing I would say. This is not really an exterior wood, so Iāll say that. Whatever you do, make it inside. Make it for inside. You can make it outside if you want, just. Yeah.
Nice. Iām glad you got that question.
Um, itās a good one for him.
All right. Next oneās from, uh, Tom Coates. As we, as we know, all of us are having problems reading today. As we know. People love when you talk about content creation. They do. Iām sure they do. After a couple of recent videos from Matt and Marc where they discussed wearing head.
Earphones in the workshop. Have you had to cut things outta video in editing that you were oblivious to when recording such as flatulence or some bad singing or even a screaming child slash wife, sorry, Shannon UPS setting off a dog. Not count as I imagine that happens quite a lot. You get a lot of deliveries there, Shannon.
No, I just have a, a blow heart of a dog.
Apparently this is happening
a lot, so I donāt know. Yeah, more than once a day leaves go by the window, like, you know, God, heās such a dick. Thatās really what it comes down to. Heās just a blow. Hod uh,
I donāt have any good examples of this. We definitely cut around, uh, screaming children in the background just because like if weāre cutting between clips of screaming versus non screaming, itās very obvious.
So weāll typically kind of cut around that, unless that like. A child chatter in the background is like a fun little allus to the fact that Iām a father and I live in a house with children. I pretty rarely do. I cut around like any swearing ācause I donāt typically do that. But that happens sometimes too.
But nothing, I donāt have any good stories for this unfortunately. Trips to the emergency
room, you cut around those, right? Yeah, that was like that one.
Anything cool that happens? A cameraās not rolling. Thatās like the worst part of my life.
Nice.
All the cool stuff. Cameraās off.
Um, I did have to cut out.
Um, it wasnāt audible flatulence, um, but my dog to the point where it was so bad that I, I started coughing in control of it was so bad. He replaced the air in the room. This was Alex. This was a while ago, but yeah, it was one of those, and I was just like, I canāt go on box.
Nice. That was bad. Uh, I sometimes include flatulence on purpose just as Mr.
Egg for I was gonna say, why would you cut that out? No. So Iāve got an editor and Iām sure heās heard plenty of things, but itās nothing I was like unaware of. I generally know when I fart, so thatās not a problem. Itās generally, no. Generally, most times Iāve reached the age where itās no longer. I know itās never a sure thing.
Generally, no. Um, I think mostly here. Itās car noise. Weāre pretty close to the road, even though itās kinda like a country location. There is, itās like a main throughway that people get to a certain town here. So around traffic time, we do get a lot of car noise. Heās gotta work around that. But really not, not a ton.
Not a ton. But that
stuff though, like Iām, I know itās going on, so Iām like working around it. Like in production, not post-production most of the time. Yeah. Like at the old house, if it was like a talking bit, we had all the airplanes flying overhead. Mm-hmm. So I had to like time all my stuff between. The, the airplaneās flying overhead.
Yeah. Here, uh, itās gunshots is Oh, nice. Is typically what Iām like in production trying to like work around Yeah. If the neighbors are shooting and Iām like, okay. Kids are out there
practicing. Yeah.
Take a pause. Yes. Yeah. Itās actually who it is. Itās the game is How fast can I empty this clip? Yeah. Well, the game is ammo is free.
Okay. You would think that itās like free ammo free. Yeah.
Yeah. Thatās weird. Nice.
Okay.
Where do we, if I shoot straight into the air, where does the bullet come back down?
I donāt, I hope theyāre not playing that game. I should.
Oh God, please.
No.
Wasnāt that, wasnāt that in grownups? That Adam Santa movie? They shoot the arrow straight up in the air.
Yeah.
Uh, alright, so we got, we did Steveās first one on the other shot. Yeah, I did that. No, this is,
this is just for you, Marc. This is the good. Worked perfectly. Yeah. Yeah. Okay.
The age old que. So, Steve Livingston, uh, the age old question that has been beaten to death is how much protection does hard wax oil.
Finishes offer. So letās move on, shall we? Uh, what I want to know is how does the appearance of hard wax oil compare to other more protective finishes? On each of my projects, I have done test samples of Rubio Osmo and odi. And by far I think the Odis looks the best. The holographic wood pop is amazing.
Maybe the tongue oil in odi. I also love the ease of use. Side note. I know that odis is a bad word, but this isnāt a discussion about CEOs that should not be spokesman for their company, uh, just like the product. And we donāt have as many hard wax options in Canada. After hearing Marc talk about armor seal, I would like to give it a try on projects where I need that added protection.
So my question is, how does hard wax oil finish like Otis compare in appearance compared to something like armor seal? Would there be any benefit to using tongue oil with armor seal as a top coat, or does armor seal just look as good as hard wax finishes on its own? For reference, the wood varieties I have available are Cherry Elm, butternut Douglas Fir.
And Poplar
a Canadian with butternut.
What? Oh, oh my God.
Thatās the same guy actually, wasnāt it? In our itās the same guy. Butternut guy. Better, better send somebody. Um, I, I think the answer is embrace David Marcs and just call it all tongue oil. Itās all use armor seal call. Itās all tongue oil. Find tongue oil.
Youāre
fine. Um, so this is interesting. Anyone who has used both of these finishes, you immediately know the difference. It is a very big difference. Um, armor seal is a diluted varnish. Itās gonna build coats. Itās gonna be a thick film. Um, itās noticeably sitting on top of the wood. Though it looks beautiful and I think it does it really well for, for what it is.
Especially if you donāt go too crazy with too many coats, it can look fantastic. Whatās that? The tool, uh, tool chest behind you. Yeah. Armor seal. Yeah, thatās Armor Seal, right? Looks great. Hard wax oils are very low Luster finishes. Thereās not a lot of sheen. Thereās no major buildup on the surface, so it, it is a very light sort of coat thatās there.
If you can call it a coat, very easy to. Yeah. I mean itās really, itās, itās not more of a
vest.
Yeah, thatās a good one. Like a shawl. Yeah. Itās more of like a sheer material kind of top, nice, sexy, itās fish vest, little sexy looking. Um, but v vastly different in, in, in what these things actually are and what they look like.
Okay. So, uh, I mean, I donāt know if I fully answered that question, but I think itās one of the reasons why people like those, uh, hard wax oil finishes. Theyāre easy to apply and they honestly just, they make the wood look good. They make it look good, and itās easy to make it look good with those finishes.
Theyāre just not offering as much protection as you would get with something like Armor Seal, which is more of a traditional finish. Itās a traditional film. And when you touch the surface, when you put a cup on the surface or a wet glass, youāre interacting with the finish and not the wood. Whereas a hard wax oil definitely puts you closer to the wood.
The things youāre putting on it are much closer to interacting with the wood layer and not a, a layer of finish, if that makes sense. Okay. Unless you guys have anything to add, we can move on to the next one. A great question here. Thanks. Very good
answer.
Mm-hmm. I think, I think Matt should demonstrate through this next question.
Yep. Go for it.
Janice Lumber industry updates something, some blah, blah, blah. Heās show.
I think thatās all it is.
That answers the question, like there has to be more, is there not more? And maybe not. I donāt remember.
I havenāt heard it in a while.
I think itās all the umba thinks in the beginning and make it feel longer.
Yeah.
Yeah. Although we, for the people listening, we, or watching someone asked, is that Matt singing the intro song to the,
oh, I didnāt even read the question yet. Okay. Nope. No, you never read the
question. They just think Matt had a stroke basically.
Yeah. You okay? Matt? You doing all right there? No, Iām with you guys.
Iām definitely not. Okay. Nope. Could be better. Fair. Enoughās like the worst. Oh, by the way, I have to ride my bike home and we have, we do have a tornado warning. Oh, nice. Right on. So, so this is gonna be good. Yeah, but itās an e-bike. Your power through that motivation and, and Nicole of course worried about the appropriate things, says, try to keep Oreo in.
Thereās a big storm coming.
Absolutely. Oreoās. Bigger role on the show than you now, at least on your socials. Who is he is? Yeah. Iām sure he gets more clicks.
Okay.
Whoās reading next? This is me, I think, right? Yep. Yeah, true. Um, this is from Stephen Clement. Whatās the deal with bandsaw blades? I hear everyone advise, throw away the blade that came with a saw, but that doesnāt come with an explanation of how to tell a good blade from a bad one.
My bandsaw has a vintage delta, so it didnāt come to me with a blade. Iāve been using Olson blades that are $20 each. Tho are those akin to the crap blades that come with saws, or are those good blades meant to replace the crap blades? Is there a price point that tells you, uh, the difference between a good or a bad blade?
Olsonās worked for me, but I know Iām missing out on some nirvana if it matters. Iām primarily hand to a woodworker, usually running a three eights four TPI blade cutting, eight quarter and thinner, uh, for rough ripped cuts and roughing out curves. Okay, good. ācause that was gonna be my first thing is like, how do you use it?
Like, I mean. If, if, if all youāre doing is resaw, then you donāt really need a, you know, you never wanna use a quarter inch blade for that. So, I donāt know. I havenāt bought a bandsaw blade in 10 years. Yeah. 15 years. 15 years. So, yeah. I. Somebody else wanna answer this? Is there a price point now? I mean, I used to think there was, there are definitely, I was a wood slicer, sall, bandsaw blade guy.
So
yeah, there are definitely different classes of bandsaw blades and you get into things like the carbide tipped blades. Yeah. Ones with specialty, you know, configurations on the teeth where you can get different results or better. Results. But I also have had issues with some of those blades in the past and Iāve had them break at the weld.
Mm-hmm. And Iām like, what am, itās like $120 mistake that was just made and Iāve gotta replace this thing. And I started to kind of come around to the other end where Iām like, you know what, that $20 blade, if it lasts me six months and I have to replace it again, Iād rather do that than have a higher end blade that keeps breaking on me.
But costs like 120, 150 bucks, maybe more. Thatās
exactly what weāve done at the lumberyard. Mm-hmm. You know? ācause they will break. Um, yeah, and we might as well just get the cheap ones to replace.
Yeah. So I, I actually donāt think thereās anything wrong and, and I think the band saw the table saw as youāre learning when youāre getting into woodworking, when people tell you itās great that you got that information, Hey, throw away that stock blade.
Itās crap. Get something else. Have you used it? Have you tried it? Because sometimes itās not completely crap. Yeah, thereās gonna be better. But this is how you amass a knowledge base of understanding of how these things work over time and what youāre paying for when you pay more. Right. So I do think itās important to actually, I.
Go ahead and use the stock blade, use it until itās not cutting well anymore. And now you have a a reference point. You have a data point that you can use when you do buy a new blade, what the difference is between that and the other one. And you still have some life in that stock blade that you can get.
You know, unless itās actively cutting poorly, thereās no reason not to use it. Itās a waste to just throw it away. Matt, you got other feelings on this?
I do the carbide thing and my blades donāt break, so Iām on the other end of like, oh, so this is my fault. That the only thing you should have, all right, because it, it cuts forever.
I just replaced my carbide blade on my, uh, the bandsaw on the shop last year sometime, and before that the blade I had on there was from 2018. Mm. Um, and the only reason I replace it is because it wasnāt quite cutting smoothly. It still cuts just fine. Yeah, but it wasnāt like nice and flat and like pretty or whatever.
It was rougher. Thatās what happens over time. They kinda wear out in that sense. But if youāre looking for rough cuts, itās fine. But I was doing some joinery so Iām like, okay, lemme just change it out. And before that I used the wood slicer blades and I would go through one of those two to three months.
Theyād only last you that long and they were like 40 something dollars at that point. So Iām like, okay. I know I switched to the car buy blades and the first one I got 30. Four months out of Wow. For four times the cost. I think it was some or somewhere around there.
So basically ask three woodworkers, get three, three different answers.
Yep. Because I never had problems with my woodsides or blades.
Like I, I had great experience with my wood. I just use āem and they got two dull. They stopped cutting straight.
Yeah. Well, thatāll do
it, I think for the volume you do, Matt. Thatās where the, the carbide really can make its money. And I donāt know whether it was a configuration problem on my saw or a bad batch.
That I kept that, that string of breaks that I kept
having. Yeah, I donāt know what the heck was up with that ācause Iāve like never had that problem with mine. Like my sawmill blades, I donāt have that problem. Like yeah, with mine either with, on the sawmill, I run carbide under there now and I have like a right, a blade per year on the sawmill and I can cut these big logs consistently, flatly, and perfectly, and cut through any crap thatās in them without worrying.
Okay. The blade costs more than the basic ones, but they actually last longer. And you actually can make it out of a cut if thereās metal in it. Mm-hmm.
You keep
cutting for the rest of the year. Wow. Versus a standard blade, you hit metal. You might not even make it outta that cut.
Yeah. Well, the good news is Steven is more confused than he was before he asked.
Welcome the question. Youāre welcome. Youāre welcome, Steven. There we go. Alright, whoās next? You up now, Matt? Uh, you are? Marc. Oh me? Yes. You. Yeah. Oh my buddy Greg. Bat. Whatās happening, Greg? Itās a winge question for Marc. Um, building a bar top, thatās my favorite. Uh, building a bar top at a solid winge for a walnut bar cabinet that has a matte finish.
Uh, itās for use in my home, not a commercial setting, so Iām not too worried about heavy duty wear and tear, and Iām comfortable making repairs if needed. Iād like the winge to appear as close to black as possible, but I also want to preserve the natural. Natural texture and feel of the wood. Nothing plasticy or overly glossy.
Boy, this is relevant to the other question that was asked. Uh, what finishing approach would you recommend to get that deep black look? While keeping the wood looking and feeling natural and still offering reasonable durability for a bar top. All right. Well of course the hard wax oils will be an opportunity here.
Thatās definitely something you can consider. Um, when it comes to wge, I think pretty much any oil-based finish is gonna turn it muddy black, like I donāt think you have to work very hard to make that happen. You can use finishes that wonāt do that. Like you might have trouble with a water-based finish on top of wge for various reasons.
Uh, maybe a certain type of lacquer, but oil in particular is gonna absorb. And thatās the thing, sometimes itās bad when you see some of the, um, you now winge has the, the darkest brown and then itās got like light brown streaks in the grain. Mm-hmm. And you wanna see that and then you go and put the, once the
chocolatey brown and it disappears.
Yeah. And it goes away real fast. So I think youāre totally fine with either a hard wax oil thatās not gonna give you a ton of protection, but you got that repairability aspect to it or other things in a case like this. I might even consider something like, um, a Danish oil, like a Waco Danish oil, one thatās basically got a little bit of oil and varnish in it.
Uh, you can get a very low luster finish. You could build as many coats as you want. With something like that, youāre wiping off the excess each time so youāre not leaving a lot of finish on the surface. So it isnāt gonna be that thick film, but it will offer a little bit. Of protection that might be helpful and water resistance and things like that.
I would definitely be looking at a, a Danish oil or something like armor seal. Again, we just talked about how different that is. That will build coats faster than something like a Danish oil, uh, which sounds like what youāre not looking for, but you can, there are things Iāve finished in the past with like one or two coats of wiped on, wiped off armor seal to try to get a little bit of protection but not go like overboard with the film thickness.
So youāve got options there, Greg.
Well, itās also such a porous wood that, you know, youād have to put a lot of coats on it to get it looking super plasticy because mm-hmm. You know,
well, and youāre gonna run into the thing, thing we, well, I was gonna say, we talked about in the last show mm-hmm. Issues Iāve had with, uh, the, the finishing shop and open poured species like that, youāre running into trouble with that because now, like you said, you build that film, itās gonna look like crap on top of that unless you do a poor fill.
Yeah. Yeah.
Okay, cool. Who next?
Last one, I think, isnāt it? Yeah. Matt, youāre up. Uh, yeah, there
we go. Um, Iām scrolling here. Oh, we did that one already. Okay. Is it Adria Adriaās question Adrian. Okay. Mm-hmm. My cheap bandsaw seems to cut all boards with a really gentle curve. They end up banana shape, like Matt Fless hand planes.
Oh, thatās a deep cut.
Is this drift or is there something else? I need to tune up. Iām just the fence to compensate for drift, but if I make a long rip cut on a long board, it ends up having a 20 foot radius curve to it. Do I either need to get a better band saw or start ripping with a frame saw? Thanks.
Oh, donāt do that. Only crazy people do that.
Thatās interesting. Iām trying to like, she is a Handel school member, so yeah. There we go. Come on. Get one of these puppies video in the Handel school on how to make this. Okay. So I have, I guess I have two things I could,
I could think
of
for those That just
goes right by that.
Okay. Bye.
Yeah, just ignore it. Itās easiest. Iām sorry, Shannon. I was, you can say your thing. No. No, not, no. Donāt, donāt let him at all. Donāt
let him
go to the hand tools. Seriously. Keep going. Get a frame saw. Okay.
First thing I wanted to just kind of bring up as a possibility is how straight is the edge of the board? Do you have against the fence? ācause if that, whatever youāre doing to achieve a straight cut on that side, if it has that same radius to it, youāre gonna be matching that radius as youāre going through along the fence.
That could be something. As, as something to think of. ācause I have, I donāt really have a good answer for this. Um, the other only thing is itās for some reason itās drifting out in the middle of the cut and then drifting back towards the end. But I donāt know why that would happen either. Um, like the cut dynamics on this donāt really make a whole lot of sense to me unless itās the board that it started with, or your technique somehow.
What about a dull blade? But it would drift in the middle. But gradually you think like that? Maybe the setās off on one side versus the other that could maybe do it. Yeah. But I donāt see it coming back though. If the set was off, it would drift away and stay away and not come back.
What if the bladeās not running true on the wheels?
Doesnāt it doesnāt, it slightly does kink the blade and make it cut in a curve. Iāve always just been told to align it, you know, and Iāve never actually put it out of alignment to see what happens, but
I just dunno if it would come. Back into a complete curve like that. The fact that Right, right. I see what youāre saying.
It would just keep, it would take out to some certain point, so you would see like a hook shape, like a big long J shape or something, but not like a big, it comes back to where it started kind of curve. Yeah.
That is weird. I mean, my first read on it, I didnāt think it was that weird of a question. Now that you mention it, that seems odd.
Yeah.
Hmm. I mean, I think the
answer is. Uh, hurry before the tariffs kick in and go buy a really nice band. Saw from Woodcraft.
Yeah, go to Woodcraft. Thereās your solution.
I hear Laguna tariffs are kicking in sometime around the middle of July. I canāt remember yet. We have all the answers.
Well, someone on there, uh, Eric mentioned, have you followed the Alex Snodgrass method?
Um, and Iāve got a video he linked to it there, uh, with Alex showing that setup method. I wonder, I mean, itās worth like,
I donāt
do the calibration, but Iām thinking like what sheās describing doesnāt necessarily sound like something that calibration would fix.
Yeah.
Hmm. Thatās a really odd problem. Hmm. I
other than to blame you and your technique, I got nothing.
Itās Adriaās fault.
I donāt like saying
that. Yeah. But I mean, per se, thereās not really a lot of technique in a band saw, right? No. Youāre just pushing. I mean, you could push,
you could push hard, you could push light, you could push fast. Yeah. You know, but youāre just pushing. I mean, the only
thing with pushing that makes sense is that youāre pushing slowly in the beginning, so itās cutting at the right speed.
Then youāre pushing too fast towards the middle, pushing too fast, and itās, so then itās, then it starts drift, and then youāre slowing down for some reason towards the end. So now itās coming back to true again.
Yeah.
Like thatās the only technique thing I can think of that would make them do
this. Well, canāt hurt to calibrate like recalibrate.
See what happens. Also, canāt hurt to address whether or not maybe you need a new blade. A dull blade on a band saw will wreak havoc. It will just do things. Yeah, itāll follow the grain. Itāll just be weird. And getting a new blade could definitely be something that will forgive a lot of those sins. You just, okay.
Go with me here. Okay, Iām ready. Weāre with you Matt. Matt actually just sparked something in my head. Pushing too fast, then too slow, then too fast. Itās only on these long boards. Well, she said it curves a lot, but if itās on a long board, address your out feed support. Um, wax your table. But then also like if, if thereās poor support.
You know, as, as sheās pushing, itās fine. But then as it starts to like cantilever off and itās kinking the blade, itās deviating and deflecting. But then, you know, as itās more and more deflected off, it re reverts back. Maybe, maybe it could be out feed support.
Yeah. Maybe try that. Thatās most things like, I just like, I wanna just go to your shop and see this and like noodle it.
Well, there you go. Donāt, thereās the answer.
One first class ticket. Matt only flies first class.
Iāve not a answer for you, but at least it would be like, oh yeah, thatās. Thatās, thatās weird. Yeah, we could always, thatās odd. Be like, oh yeah. Weird. Thatās odd. Thanks for
the video. That was weird. Yeah. I mean, she, she could, she could just film the whole thing or that, um, you know, so I donāt know.
On a cheap bandsaw, she probably doesnāt have this option. But one thing I, that I saw Philip Morley do on my bandsaw, we were doing a lamination bent lamination video. Um, he pulled my fence. Forward, mm-hmm. Like on the in feed side, so that once itās past the blade, he cares a lot less about whatās happening.
So sometimes if thereās some weirdness in your fence, youāre influencing the, the direction of the cut and the orientation of the cut. If the fence extends a lot further past the back of the blade. Past
the blade. Yeah.
So most of the references happening before the cut and then after the cut doesnāt really matter so much what happens as long as you have more runway to keep pressed up against the fence.
So I donāt know if the, a cheap band saw. Typically is not gonna allow you to do that, but maybe add a sacrificial or a, a supplemental fence face on there. A standoff
kind of thing?
Yeah. Yeah. So you have a little bit more room to work with of the same principle and like the s saw fence that allows you to micro steer.
Put a flat fence, but donāt extend it through the blade, put it ahead of the blade. And, and yeah, thatād be an interesting test. Itās certainly cheap enough to take a scrap block and throw it there.
I think thatās where sheās at now, is you gotta, you gotta change some things and do some more cuts, start messing with it.
Just that like the bandsaw might be one of the trickiest things to, at least for me, I find it to be one of the trickiest tools to diagnose a specific problem and fix.
I just never relied on it for precision, and I know thatās wrong because thereās been some incredible precision coming out of. Proper setup, but I was always just using it like ripping a roughs on board, like I was using it because I wouldnāt get kickback or whatever.
Mm-hmm. Or I was free handing a cut or any of the res sawing I did with a, you know, with a point fence. So I was micro steering anyway. I just never relied on it for perfectly straight cuts, you know, that was a table saw in my mind.
A lot of this stuff I donāt have to think about anymore. ācause of the carbide blades, you donāt have to.
Even 200 saw. At least I donāt. There we go. Yeah. Like my guides arenāt touching, Iām missing a guide on my lowers. Itās like thereās no side support guide down there. Mm-hmm. I donāt really know what the drift angle is, ācause it doesnāt matter either. So there you
go, Adria. Buy a bandsaw blade that probably costs more than your bandsaw.
Iām,
thatās the, the crappy answer. I donāt,
I mean, thatās one way to get better results. Um, Iāve done that in the past. Get a good quality immune, spend the table saw, spend more money. Itās always a good way to get good results. That is generally my solution to all. As long as you spend money at
Woodcraft.
Yeah. Oh, thatās good. Alright, well look, that was it. You guys asked great questions. Thank you for your support. Uh, that means a lot to us and if this helped you, and hopefully it did for some of you, probably not Adria,
but everybody else. Sorry. Sorry. If we didnāt please ask another question, weāre sorry.
Yeah.
Weāll do better eight next time. I guess. Ask again next time.
Ask again later. Thatās what we need. We need a wood talk eight ball. Yeah,
yeah, yeah, thatād be perfect. Oh, man. Alright, well we really appreciate you guys listening, asking those questions. And of course, thanks to our sponsor, Woodcraft, for sponsoring the show.
Uh, check āem out@woodcraft.com. All right, thanks for listening, everybody, and weāll see you next time. Iāll, who knows? You never know.
20 replies on “WT299 – Don’t Shave Your Adopted Children”
Great show guys!
Kids are, by nature, very inquisitive and capable of learning a LOT. For instance, this amazing video of a 3 1/2 year old toddler that can name 75 shop tools:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wAqfJJ2F6iM
An additional thumbs up for the Mortise & Tenon journal. The quality of the writing, imagery, content, paper weight & texture, and packaging is top-notch. On the show, giggled about the packaging – it’s true, though. As I opened the mailer, I unveiled a hand-tied brown paper baggy and a bunch of wood shavings fell out.
If you are interested in woodworking (regardless of your methods), this journal is something you should invest in. Although the focus of Mortise & Tenon is pre-industrial woodworking practice, the treatise at the start of this first edition explains some of reasoning for that methodology.
Get it… it’s good.
And thereby hide away the adopted kids from discussion? That hurts them more than the jokes.
I think you replied to the wrong comment. You can discuss adopted kids if you want (not relevant for WoodTalk, though). But don’t imply adopted kids are different to the parents than biological (I have both). If you have other ideas, it would be best to find another venue.
Shannon: skip the adopted kid jokes. My wife would come down on you like a ton of bricks if she heard that. We actually had someone ask, “if it doesn’t work out, can you send him back?”
Thanks for the rest, guys.
See, I knew you’d get in trouble Shannon! š
I interpreted Shannon’s comment as satire. I assumed he was making fun of the people that make those kinds of jokes.
Yeah I do believe it was completely intended as satire.
I have copied the picture on page 30 of M&T and have hung it in my shop.
Mortise & Tenon? Get it⦠itās good.
In the discussion about the plane mouths, I wanted to also mention that instead of moving the frog back and forth, you can adjust the cap iron. I generally set the cap iron a hair back of the thickness of the shaving i want to take. For smoothing operations this can be .002-.003″ and for heavier cuts I may set it back a sixteenth (or more. It doesn’t really do anything at that point). My smoothers are usually set very tight, but my jointer alternates between heavy and thin cuts all the time. I have found this to be tremendously effective at controlling tearout, and though it can be a bit difficult to master, once you “get it” you can really set a plane with a super wide mouth to take any kind of cut. Richard (of englishwoodworker fame) has a video on this which I highly encourage:
http://www.theenglishwoodworker.com/cap-irons-tear-out-video/
Hey guys –
I think it’s funny how you can complain about bubble wrapping our kids these days, but imagine this – Mateo comes home from his friend’s house and says “Jimmy’s mom let us use her knitting needles today – I think I have a real knack for it!”
You’ll be changing your tune real quick.
Great show as always!
With regards to children in the shop:
ā…children ought to have attained the degree of development which corresponds roughly to 10 or 11 years. Otherwise they cannot be expected to meet the demands made on the spirit of self-reliance during work. At the same time, as children of the same age differ greatly in point of development our guiding principle should not be the date of birth, but the mental and physical powers which the child has at command. What one child of nine years can accomplish with ease may be beyond the powers of another child of twelve.ā (The Teacherās Handbook of Slƶjd, Otto Salomon, 1892, p.17)
So back in the day, they used to put a sharp knife in their hands and ready to work by themselves as early as age 9.
https://archive.org/details/teachershandbook00salo
Marc,
You were talking about building a shed for your cut offs. I just checked and the web domain name “thewoodhoarder.com” is available. You might want to jump on that….
ha!!
When I was 8 or 9, everyone I knew could hammer a nail or cut a board. All my friends had a Swiss Army type pocket knife. And if you did well in school, you got an air rifle for Xmas.
Today’s parents are such wusses.
Matt,
I was the one that sent in that sawmill video from episode 298. If you name your homemade sawmill the “MattMizer” I will be so excited. Also I will name my first child after you..which Matt isnt really a crazy name to name my kid..unless it is a girl..that could be weird. Okay maybe I wont name my kid after you but good luck with the build.
I’ll have to speak with my attorney about that name for my mill. Should be a fun discussion haha!
As a carpenter I’ve enjoyed listening to you guys and gaining some woodworking tricks I can use for different things in houses. I don’t have a full on shop at my house but occasionally do use tools at home and my young kids love to watch and “help” (which usually means holding the glue bottle or tape measure until i need it.) I don’t have an issue with anyone letting their kids use tools as long as they’re taught proper safety for them. That said some people have different opinions on how dangerous some tools are. For example, my kids love stretching out my tape measure as far as they can and then wrapping it up again. Not something I worry about in the least as I have only ever cut myself with broken tapes, but when my mother-in-law visited she made it seem like it was the most dangerous thing in the house because they MIGHT cut their fingers when it retracted. As a side note, they’ve spent many hours playing and never had a problem before. She has cut herself on a tape measure though and so the measure game ended. Can’t wait until she shows up in a few years and they’re using the table saw….
My daughter is 2 1/2 and likes to wander around the shop while I work. Mostly I keep a close eye on her but let her wander. Obviously at that age she can’t do anything but I don’t see the harm in letting her hang out if that is what she wants to do. I would say I am the opposite of a helicopter parent. I was using circular saws and drills by the time I was 10 or 11. Yes, there are plenty of ways she could hurt herself just wandering around my pit of a shop but that is simply not the sort of thing I worry about. I think the benefits of her hanging out with me outweight the risks of her getting a splinter or whatever.
My boys are 8 and 11. I’d let them use the bandsaw, a handheld jig saw, handheld drills, and thickness planer under close supervision. I wouldn’t let them use my tablesaw, router/router table or jointer yet. Maybe around age 13. Really does depend on the kid though.
As a father of four and a grandfather of thirteen I was interested in your discussion regarding the neighbour who would not let her son play with his friend in the woodwork shop. Personally I think that she was a psycho. I could go on and explain in detail why I think that this is the case but this overprotective attitude teaches the son nothing except fear and paranoia. Sure, it is important to be safe but not at the cost of experience and education.
The problem is there is nothing you can do about this overprotective attitude. I really don’t think it is modern society, I have known people like this all my life. I am just too old to have any patience for them any more.